Comparison of Percutaneous versus Open Surgical techniques for placement of Peritoneal Dialysis Catheters
Résumé
Background: Nephrologists have used percutaneous placements of peritoneal dialysis catheters (PDCs) with or without fluoroscopic guidance. PDCs are also placed using mini-laparotomy and laparoscopic techniques by surgeons. Percutaneous PDC placement by nephrologists is a simple, non-invasive technique with minimum intraoperative morbidity. We compared operative and immediate complications of PDCs using percutaneous versus open surgical mode of insertion.
Methods: Data of all patients entering into CAPD programme in our center between July 2011 to July 2015 was collected. A total of 377 PDCs had been inserted over 48 months in 358 patients. Of 377 catheters inserted, 224 had been inserted by percutaneous method and 153 by surgical technique.
Results: Wound hematoma developed in 3.5% of percutaneously placed catheters vs 2.6% of catheters placed by surgical technique, p-0.061. Haemorrhagic effluent was seen in 4.46% of percutaneously placed catheters vs 3.92% of surgically placed catheters, p-0.068. Bowel injury occurred in 1.33% of percutaneously placed catheters vs 0.65% of surgically placed catheters, p-0159. Dialysate leak occurred in 2.6% of catheters placed percutaneously vs 6.5% of catheters placed by surgical technique, p-0.068. Percutaneous PDC allowed a significantly shorter hospital stay, smaller wound size and less break-in period
Conclusions: Percutaneously placed CAPD catheters by nephrologists ensues significantly less hospital stay, small sized incision, lesser break-in period and less post-surgical morbidity as compared with surgically placed catheters. Percutaneous PDC placement is minimally invasive, safe, less time consuming and dependable peritoneal access technique.
##plugins.generic.usageStats.downloads##
Références
2. Asif A, Byers P, Viera CF, Roth D. Developing a comprehensive diagnostic and interventional nephrology program at an academic center. Am J Kidney Dis.2003; 42:229-33
3. Comert M, Borazan A, Kulah E, A new laparoscopy technique for placement of a permanent peritoneal dialysis catheter; the peritoneal tunnelling method. Surg Endosc. 2005 Feb;19(2):245-48.
4. Degesys GE, miller GA, ford KK. Tenckhoff peritoneal dialysis catheters: the use of fluoroscopy in management. Radiology.1985;154:819-20
5. Zaman F, pervez A, Atray NK. Fluoroscopy assisted placement of peritoneal dialysis catheters by nephrologists. Semin Dial.2005;18:247-51
6. Hendersons, Brown E, Lvy J. Safety and efficacy of percutaneous insertion of peritoneal dialysis catheters under sedation and local anaesthetic. Nephrol Dial Transplant 2009; 24:3499-509.
7. Ozener C, Bihoric A, Akolglu E. Technical survival of CAPD catheters: comparison between percutaneous and conventional surgical placement techniques. Nephrol Dial transplant 2001; 16:1893-9
8. Mellotte GJ, Ho CA, Morgan SH, Bending MR, Eisinger AJ. Peritoneal dialysis catheters: a comparison between percutaneous and conventional surgical placement techniques. Nephrol Dial Transplan1993:8:626-30
9. Jo YI, Shin SK, Lee JH, Song JO, Park JH. Immediate initiation of CAPD following percutaneous catheter placement without break-in procedure. Perit Dial Int. 2007; 27:179–83.
10. Moreiras PM, Cuina L, Goyanes GR, Sobrado JA, Gonlez L. Mechanical complications in chronic peritoneal dialysis. Clin Nephrol 1999; 52:124-30.
11. Smith SA, Morgan SH, Eastwood JB. Routine percutaneous insertion of permanent peritoneal dialysis catheters on the nephrology ward. Perit Dial Int 1994; 14:284-86.
12. Allom M, Soucie JM, Macon EJ. Complications with permanent peritoneal dialysis catheters: Experience with 154 percutaneously placed catheters. Nephron 1988; 48: 8-11.
